Insights
Find the latest news and insights from TrueShares below.
When the Discount Becomes an Opportunity: Finding a Different Source of Alpha in Closed-End Funds

In closed-end funds, price and value don't always move together.
A fund's underlying portfolio has a net asset value, but its shares trade independently on an exchange. Changes in investor sentiment, interest rates, tax-loss selling and other market forces can cause the market price to diverge from Net Asset Value, sometimes significantly.
That gap is one of the defining features of closed-end fund investing. And in today's market, it's worth a closer look.
The Market Is Pricing More Than the Assets
Closed-end fund (CEF) discounts are influenced by much more than underlying fundamentals. Interest rates, volatility, macroeconomic sentiment, distribution policies, manager reputation and simple investor supply and demand can all affect where a CEF trades relative to its NAV. That creates a fundamental distinction.
Consider a hypothetical credit portfolio with a NAV of $100. If investors can purchase the closed-end fund holding that portfolio for $85, they are gaining exposure to $100 of underlying net assets for $85. If the underlying portfolio is unchanged but the discount subsequently narrows from 15% to 8%, the market price moves from $85 to $92, producing approximately an 8.2% gain before distributions, fees and expenses. If instead the discount widened from 15% to 22%, the market price would fall from $85 to $78, a loss of approximately 8.2%, even though the underlying portfolio was unchanged.**
The investor did not need credit spreads to tighten for that particular source of return. The discount itself did some of the work.
Of course, the reverse is equally important: discounts can widen further, amplifying losses even when the underlying assets are relatively stable. There is no assurance that a discount will narrow.
Why Discounts May Look Particularly Interesting Now
We believe what's notable about today's closed-end fund market isn't simply that discounts are wide. It's how uneven those discounts have become. Parts of the traditional credit CEF universe are trading near historically wide discount levels, while heightened concerns about private credit have pushed discounts on some funds to 30% to 50%***.
That dispersion is occurring against a backdrop of broad interest-rate-driven selling across stocks and bonds. In some instances, that selling has affected closed-end funds even when their underlying portfolios carry relatively little duration. When market price moves become increasingly influenced by a common macro factor, the relationship between price, NAV and underlying portfolio risk becomes especially important to evaluate.
Searching for Alpha in the Gap
The opportunity in closed-end funds is not simply to find the widest discount.
Hypothetical Example: A 20% discount can become a 30% discount. A large distribution can be cut. Leverage can magnify adverse moves. And a fund can remain inexpensive for years if there is no reason for investor demand to return.
It's important to determine whether a discount represents compensation for genuine fundamental risk or a market-price dislocation that has become excessive.
That means asking questions such as:
- What does the underlying portfolio actually own?
- How much leverage does the fund employ?
- Does the distribution appear sustainable?
- What is the fund's duration and true credit exposure?
- How has management historically approached distributions, repurchases or capital raising?
- Is tax-loss selling or another temporary technical factor affecting the price?
- What could cause the discount to normalize?
A Different Source of Potential Return
Many traditional investment decisions begin with a view on the underlying asset. Will rates fall? Will credit spreads tighten? Will equities rise?
Closed-end fund discount trading adds another dimension. An investor can have one view on the assets inside a fund and a separate view on how the fund itself is priced.
That distinction can be important because changes in a CEF’s discount can contribute to returns independently of changes in its NAV. A discount may narrow even if the underlying portfolio has not appreciated. Conversely, a widening discount can detract from returns even when the underlying assets are relatively stable. This creates a potential return driver that is separate from changes in duration, credit or equity exposure. However, a CEF investor remains exposed to the risks of the underlying portfolio, and discount changes.
Discount trading focuses less on predicting the next macro move and more on identifying potential differences between the price of a fund and the characteristics of the assets underneath it.
Investor Behavior Can Create Another Variable
Tax-loss selling offers a useful example. Toward year-end, investors may sell positions that have declined in value to realize losses for tax purposes. In closed-end funds, that additional selling pressure can affect the market price and, in turn, the discount to NAV.
Historically, some of that pressure has reversed after year-end. Since 1996, CEF discounts have narrowed the most in January compared with every other month, with the pattern occurring approximately 90% of the time. In January 2026, the All CEF PGI discount narrowed by 59 basis points, from -5.54% to -4.95%*.
The takeaway is not that investors should simply buy CEFs in December and sell them in January. Rather, it illustrates an important characteristic of the market: a CEF’s price can sometimes be influenced by who is buying and selling, and why, rather than solely by changes in the value of the underlying portfolio.
For active managers, that can create opportunities to distinguish between a change in fundamentals and a temporary change in supply and demand.
Where Discount Trading May Fit in a Portfolio
For financial advisors, the case for CEF discount trading is not that it replaces traditional equity or fixed-income investing. It is that it introduces another potential return driver alongside those exposures. Equity returns are influenced by factors such as earnings, valuations and market sentiment. Fixed-income returns are influenced by interest rates, credit spreads, defaults and the shape of the yield curve. CEF investors also have to account for another variable: the movement of the market price relative to NAV.
Those forces can certainly interact. In periods of market stress, discounts can widen across many CEF categories at once. There is no guarantee that discount trading will diversify a portfolio or produce positive returns. But the source of potential return is different. Discount changes can be influenced by investor flows, sentiment, tax-related selling, distribution policies and other technical factors in addition to movements in the underlying assets.
That can be the rationale behind actively trading CEF discounts rather than simply buying a collection of high-yielding funds and holding them indefinitely. It is also central to the strategy of the RiverNorth Active Income ETF (CEFZ). The fund primarily allocates among closed-end funds and ETFs and uses both short- and long-term trading strategies to seek value from changes in CEF discounts and premiums.
The goal is not simply to own discounted funds. It is to actively assess whether those discounts represent risk, opportunity or some combination of the two.
The Bottom Line
Wide discounts alone do not make a closed-end fund attractive. Other interesting situations can arise when the price investors are assigning to a fund appears disconnected from the characteristics of the portfolio underneath it.
That is especially relevant in a market where discount dispersion is significant. Observations from the current CEF market include traditional credit trading at historically wide discount levels in some areas, private-credit funds at discounts of roughly 30% to 50% in certain cases***. The challenge is determining which discounts adequately reflect fundamental risk and which may be driven, at least partly, by sentiment, liquidity or technical selling.
-----------------
*Source: https://www.true-shares.com/insights/cef-january-effect-2026
**Hypothetical illustration — not performance. The example shows how a change in a closed-end fund’s discount can affect its market price when the underlying NAV is unchanged. It does not represent any actual fund or investment, excludes distributions, fees, expenses and brokerage commissions, and is not a forecast.
***Source: RiverNorth, FactSet as of 10/8/2026
Alpha is a measure of an investment's performance that indicates its ability to generate returns in excess of its benchmark. Net asset value (NAV) is the difference between a company's assets and its liabilities calculated at the end of each business day. A credit spread is the difference in yield between two debt securities with different credit quality but the same maturity. A CEF trades at a discount when its market price per share is lower than its NAV per share. Duration estimates the change in a bond's price when interest rates move. A yield curve is a line that plots the yields or interest rates of bonds that have equal credit quality but different maturity dates.
Past performance is no guarantee of future results. There is no assurance that the investment process will consistently lead to successful investing. Discount trading involves its own judgments and risks; a discount may persist or widen for extended periods. Discounts and premiums may fluctuate and may widen or narrow. There is no assurance that a Fund’s discount will narrow or that its shares will trade at or above NAV. Shares of closed-end funds may trade at a premium or discount to their net asset value (NAV). The market price of Fund shares may be more or less than the Fund’s NAV, and there can be no assurance that shares will trade at, above, or near NAV.
Thought Leadership,
Straight to Your Inbox
Disclosures
©2026, TrueShares, ©2026 TrueMark Investments, LLC. (“TrueMark”).
Before investing, carefully consider the TrueShares ETFs investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. Specific information about TrueShares is contained in the prospectus and a summary prospectus, copies of which may be obtained by visiting www.true-shares.com. Read the prospectus carefully before you invest.
An investment in TrueShares is subject to numerous risks, including possible loss of principal. The ETFs are subject to the following principal risks: Authorized Participants, Market Makers, and Liquidity Providers Concentration Risk associated with ETFs; Equity Market Risk; Management Risk; Market Capitalization Risk (Large Cap; Mid Cap, Small Cap Stock); Market Risk; New Fund Risk: The Fund is a recently organized, non-diversified management investment company with no operating history. As a result, prospective investors have no track record or history on which to base their investment decision. Additionally, the Adviser has not previously managed a registered fund, which may increase the risks of investing in the Fund.
Depositary Receipts Risk. American Depositary Receipts (“ADRs”) have risks similar to those of foreign securities (political and economic conditions, changes in the exchange rates, etc.) and entitle the holder to all dividends and capital gains that are paid out on the underlying foreign shares.
Individual investors should contact their financial advisor or broker dealer representative for more information on TrueShares ETFs.
Investment Products and Services are: NOT FDIC INSURED / MAY LOSE VALUE / NO BANK GUARANTEE.
All registered investment companies, including TrueShares, are obliged to distribute portfolio gains to shareholders at year-end regardless of performance. Trading in TrueShares ETFs will also generate tax consequences and transaction expenses. The information provided is not intended to be tax advice. Tax consequences of dividend distributions may vary by individual taxpayer.
TrueShares ETFs are bought and sold through exchange trading at market price, not Net Asset Value (NAV), and are not individually redeemed from the fund. Shares may trade at a premium or discount to their NAV in the secondary market. Brokerage commissions will reduce returns.
ETF shares may be bought or sold throughout the day at their market price, not their NAV, on the exchange on which they are listed. Shares of ETFs are tradable on secondary markets and may trade either at a premium or a discount to their NAV on the secondary market. ETFs trade like stocks, fluctuate in market value and may trade at prices above or below the ETF’s NAV. Brokerage commissions and ETF expenses will reduce returns.
Fund Intelligence Mutual Fund Industry and ETF Award shortlists and winners are comprised of individuals and firms who have submitted entries or been nominated via the online submission process, as well as through recommendations from leading market participants. Fund Intelligence Mutual Fund Industry and ETF Award judges will use the submitted application material, as well as any uploaded supplemental information, to determine which firm, individual or product they believe to be the most suitable and deserving winners for each category. Fund Intelligence Mutual Fund Industry and ETF Award judges have the discretionary power to move nominations into alternative categories that they think may be more suitable. Fund Intelligence Mutual Fund Industry and ETF Awards were decided by an independent panel of 20 judges with expertise across the asset management space.
TrueShares ETFs (the “Funds”) are registered with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission under the Investment Company Act of 1940. The fund is distributed by Paralel Distributors LLC, Member FINRA. Paralel is not affiliated with TrueMark Investments, LLC. TrueMark Investments, LLC, is the investment advisor to the Funds and receives a fee from the Funds for its services.
TrueMark Investments, LLC is the investment advisor to the Funds and receives a fee from the Funds for its services.
TrueShares ETFs are offered only to United States residents, and information on this site is intended only for such persons. Nothing on this website should be considered a solicitation to buy nor an offer to sell shares of any fund in any jurisdiction where the offer or solicitation would be unlawful under the securities laws of such jurisdiction.

